Mile Marker 100, Key Largo

Two shops.
One family.
A whole lotta chocolate.

Hand-crafted truffles, our famous Key Lime Pie, 36 flavors of ice cream, and a Florida Keys vacation tradition since 2010 - from the Peterson family. Two shops along US-1, in Key Largo and Islamorada.

★★★★★ 4.6 / 5 from 671 Tripadvisor reviews
Keys Chocolates & Ice Cream - hand-crafted truffles, 36 ice cream flavors, and famous Key Lime Pie
Hand-crafted in Key Largo
4.6 ★ from 671 Tripadvisor reviews 16 years in the Keys 36 flavors of ice cream - and counting
The Peterson Family

From a Minnesota chocolate shop to Mile Marker 100.

Sweets are a family legacy for Bronna and Rich Peterson. Bronna's grandmother owned her own restaurant and bakery - pies, cakes, cookies, the works. Rich's family owned Ramer's Chocolates & Confectionary, a name Minnesotans knew for decades.

In 2010, they brought the recipes south. The first shop opened in Key Largo. Sixteen years later - and a second shop down the road in Islamorada - they're still hand-crafting truffles in the back of the Key Largo shop and pulling Key Lime Pies out of the same family oven.

"We can't wait to see you in the Keys." - Rich & Bronna Peterson, owners
Inside the Keys Chocolates shop at Mile Marker 100, Key Largo - where the truffles are made by hand
2010family-owned since

Hand-crafted in Key Largo. Famous from Miami to Marathon.

Our truffles are made by hand in the back of the Key Largo shop. Our Key Lime Pie is baked the same way Bronna's grandmother taught her. See both shops

An assorted box of hand-crafted Keys Chocolates truffles

The Truffle Box

Hard chocolate shells, decadent ganache centers - every truffle hand-rolled and dipped. Pick from a rotating menu of flavors: dark chocolate sea salt, key lime, espresso, raspberry, peanut butter, and the rest. Build your own assortment.

Famous
A whole Key Lime Pie from Keys Chocolates

Key Lime Pie

Whole pies and frozen pie bars. The recipe people drive down Highway 1 for.

Ice cream sundae from Keys Chocolates

36 Flavors of Ice Cream

Plus sorbetto, scooped at the counter all day. Cones, cups, sundaes, banana splits.

Chocolate covered pretzels and confections

Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Big pretzel rods dipped in milk or dark, then drizzled, sprinkled, or rolled.

Local Favorite
Gator Crunch - a Florida Keys local-favorite chocolate

Gator Crunch

The Florida Keys-only flavor that locals come in for.

Two shops along US-1. Same family. Same recipes.

Driving the Keys? Stop at the Key Largo shop, or pull off at Islamorada. Both shops have the same hand-crafted truffles and Key Lime Pie - and a few signatures of their own.
The Keys Chocolates Islamorada storefront on Mile Marker 81.9, with the pink and green facade and the KEYS Chocolates flamingo door 2 Islamorada

Islamorada

81933 Overseas Hwy
Islamorada, FL 33036

Sun-Thu: 2pm – 9pm
Fri-Sat: 12pm – 10pm
36 ice cream flavors at the counter
Frozen Key Lime Bars
Beyond the Counter

When you need more than a box of truffles.

Wedding cakes for 200, dessert tables for the corporate retreat, or wholesale by the case for your gift shop - all handled out of the Key Largo kitchen.

A Keys Chocolates dessert table set up for an event

Weddings & Events

Cakes, dessert tables, favors, sundae bars.

From custom wedding cakes to dessert tables, chocolate favors, and ice cream sundae bars - we handle weddings, corporate retreats, family reunions, and Keys-area parties out of the Key Largo kitchen. Pickup from either shop or delivery in the Keys corridor.

Plan your event
A Keys Chocolates staff member with a wholesale truffle box

Wholesale

Resorts, gift shops, and bakery accounts.

Resorts, gift shops, and bakery accounts across South Florida already stock our truffles, pretzels, and Key Lime products. Custom case pricing, white-label options for partner brands, and consistent supply straight out of the Key Largo kitchen.

Become a partner
Two Keys Chocolates team members behind the counter holding ice cream cones

Work for Us

Join the Keys Crew.

We are always looking for friendly faces to scoop ice cream, dip truffles, and make somebody's day at the counter. Flexible shifts, family-run, and yes - you can eat the chocolate.

See open positions

671 reviews. 4.6 stars. One favorite stop.

★★★★★
Across Tripadvisor and Yelp - ranked #9 of 118 Key Largo restaurants.
Common Questions

Before you make the drive.

Anything else? Call the Key Largo shop at (305) 453-6613 or send a note from the contact form below.

Two Florida storefronts along US-1. The Key Largo shop is at 100470 Overseas Hwy - that's where the truffles and pies are made. Our Islamorada shop is at 81933 Overseas Hwy. Hours and full directions are in the "Visit Us" section above.
Yes. Every truffle is hand-rolled and hand-dipped in the back of the Key Largo shop using recipes from Rich Peterson's family confectionery - Ramer's Chocolates of Minnesota. The flavor lineup rotates seasonally; you'll find dark chocolate sea salt, key lime, espresso, raspberry, peanut butter, and a few wild cards on any given visit.
Yes - we ship our chocolate, candy, and gift assortments anywhere in the continental US through our online shop. Ice cream and frozen Key Lime Pie bars are pickup-only at the shops. For wedding favor or large gift orders, email info@keylargochocolates.com.
Absolutely - weddings and events are a major part of what we do. Custom cakes, chocolate dessert tables, favor trays, you name it. Reach out at events@keylargochocolates.com or call our events line at (561) 568-2882. High season books out months in advance.
Yes. We supply resorts, gift shops, and bakery accounts across the Keys and South Florida - truffles, chocolate-covered pretzels, Florida Keys Sampler boxes, and our Key Lime products. Email info@keylargochocolates.com to open an account.
For private events, the team can accommodate small groups and tasting parties at the Key Largo shop, and runs full-service custom events out of the same kitchen. Email events@keylargochocolates.com with your group size and date.
Lucy lives at our Key Largo and Islamorada shops. Bring the kids; she's an excellent photo subject and tag @keylargochocolates on Instagram so we can see it.
We carry sorbetto and several non-dairy options at the ice cream counter, and several of our chocolate items are naturally dairy-free dark chocolate. Specific allergen and dietary questions are best answered by calling the shop you're planning to visit so we can walk you through the day's case.

Send us a note.

Wedding inquiries, catering questions, wholesale opens, or just a hello from the road - the Petersons and the Keys Crew read every message.

Key Largo
100470 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
Islamorada
81933 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Weddings & Events
Custom cakes, dessert tables, and chocolate-favor trays - handled out of the Key Largo kitchen.